Energy consumption in cold chains has been predicted to rise significantly in view of the increasing world population. Of critical attention is the increasing number of road transport refrigeration which is highly gaining enormous ground globally. In view of the fact that 40% of all foods require refrigeration, 15% of world fossil fuel energy is used in food transport refrigeration. This concern necessitates this study to examine cold chain system with the emphasis on the impact of energy consumption in sustaining the shelf life of fresh food. As the world continues to battle with the global warming occasioned by emission of carbon dioxide from fossil fuel, this study identifies alternative means of saving energy in food transportation system through minimizing energy consumption in diesel engine driven vapour compression system. Preserving perishable fresh food (mainly vegetable) under sub-zero weather is another debacle the authors envisaged in the quest to reduce fossil fuel consumption. This process requires heating the mechanical refrigeration unit in a reverse-cycle to raise the temperature at 0 °C which may further result in more energy demand. The conclusion drawn from this study could be useful in re-designing food transport system for optimal energy saving.
Environment; Cold chain; Shelf life; Refrigerated vehicles; Fresh food
Prolonging shelf life of fresh food is vital in sustenance of perishable raw food items. Preserving food is prevalent in the world today as most homes engage in these practices through refrigeration system . Food transport system is another medium of conveying fresh raw food to a possible distant location and it is expected the transportation channels are kept at low temperature conditions (−4 °C to 4 °C) to prolong shelf life and maintain quality of the products. In view of the importance of food transport refrigeration system, United Nation adopted an inter-governmental Agreement on Transportation of Perishable food stuff (ATP) and this agreement provides a specification on insulated body and equipment . Refrigerated vehicles body walls are insulated against heat transfer from ambient temperature into the cooling chamber and ATP developed a blueprint for insulations and equipment to reduce payload on vehicular engine. This agreement classifies transportation equipment (insulation and body wall) as either normally insulated (where the overall heat transfer coefficient U is equal or less than 0.7 W/m2 K) or heavily Insulated (in which U coefficient equals to or less than 0.4 W/m2 K). This agreement appeared to have provided the platform for insulating the body wall and despite this regulation, energy consumption in cold chain is still a global challenge and it is reported to account for 30% of total world energy consumption . In the same vein, Meneghetti and Monti  have reported that over 40% of all food require refrigeration and about 15% of the same food are being refrigerated due to energy shortfall. In the study conducted by Glouannec et al. , it is reported that there are estimated 4 million food transport vehicles in the world and predicted 2.5% increase in the global road freight transport by 2030. This prediction is catastrophic considering the environmental impact of cold chain in view of its energy consumption and emerging implication.
World leaders are currently faced with the challenge of climate change and every resources are being deplored to mitigate its impact on the environment. Sustaining the nature and the climatic environment is a big task to avoid impending and looming danger. Many researchers  and  have predicted that the world may naturally go into oblivion if sustainable and pragmatic steps are not taken to reduce fossil fuel consumption which is widely acknowledged to be the major source of carbon emission. Diesel engine driven vapour compression system accounts for huge fuel drain in transport system. A significant CO2 emission from the refrigerant leakage has equally been source of concern in food transport system. Tassou et al.  have studied diesel engine driven vapour compression refrigeration system and concluded that 40% of the greenhouse gas emission results from vehicle’s engine and refrigerant leakage. Multi-drop temperature controlled refrigeration system is reported to consume more energy in food chain due to air infiltration as a result of frequent door opening. Table 1 shows CO2 emission from vehicle engines using an emissions factor for diesel of 2.668 kg CO2 per litre. For a 38 ton articulated vehicle class, the CO2 emission of 58 kg CO2/pallet-km is recorded while 115 kg CO2/pallet is reported for multi-drop frozen medium rigid vehicle class. Also, CO2 emission from refrigerant leakage is also a cause of concern to many environmentalists  and . Based on the above, alternative refrigerant may be the best option for refrigerant R404A which has been criticized to be a major contribution to global warming in view of its incessant leakage which could raise the CO2 emissions from food transport system up to 40% from the vehicle engine (see Table 2). Finnveden et al.  have similarly reported 21% of annual refrigerant leakages which is also in the range predicted by Tassou et al. . This study gives the impact of food preservation system on the environment in view of the energy consumption associated with the process. Energy utilisation is a key to social modernization and efforts must be intensified to adopt best international practices to combat climate change which is now a global monster.
|Category of vehicle||Room condition or ambient||Single drop (chilled)||Multi-drop (chilled)||Single-drop (frozen and varying temperature condition)||Multi-drop (frozen and varying temperature condition)|
|32 ton articulated vehicles||56||69||70||73||75|
|38 ton articulated vehicles||51||61||63||65||67|
|Vehicle class||Refrigerant charge (kg)||Average volume load||Annual leakage rate for R404A (per cent of system charge)|
|32 ton articulated vehicles||6.5||11.24||1.1||2.2||2.6||4.5||5.6||6.7|
|38 ton articulated vehicles||7.0||14.38||0.9||1.9||2.5||3.8||4.7||5.6|
Preserving quality of fresh food involves a multi-dimensional chain system in which these foods are refrigerated at a lower temperature condition. Different temperature requirements exist in fresh products and these temperature requirements must be sustained to keep these products alive (Table 3).
|Fresh food||Temperature requirement (°C)|
|Fresh fish (in ice), crustaceans and shellfish (excluding live ones)||+2|
|Meat and cooked meats pre-packaged for consumer use||+3|
|Cooked meats other than those which have been salted, smoked, dried or sterilized||+6|
|Butter and edible fats, including cream to be used for butter making||−14|
|Deep frozen foods||−18|
In developing countries where there is enormous shortfall in power generation and also lack of technical know-how to explore environmental friendly energy, fossil fuel is highly explored as alternative means of energy. This convectional fuel source has been widely reported  as global emission of carbon dioxide which is a major contributor to global warming. Keeping raw food in a cold store is purposely for preserving quality. Table 4 shows specification of energy consumption in cold store.
|Cold store sizes||Energy requirement (kW h/m3 year)|
Fresh food transport system is another cold chain where huge volume of energy is needed to keep raw food in safety condition. Transportation of fresh food through diesel engine driven vapour compression refrigeration system is energy intensive especially in multi-drop system. The study performed by Dincer  investigated energy application and its environmental impact. The article noted that environmental impact of energy use will continue to be felt in developing countries as highly developed countries continue to expand their industrialized base in developing countries. Several demographers have envisaged that the world population will hit a record high of 15 billion in 2030 and 60% of these people will reside in developing countries. To further illustrate fossil fuel consumption in cold chain, Tassou et al.  embarked on a study to access the performance of refrigerated road vehicles with emphasis on diesel consumption in different classes of vehicle type. The result is shown in Table 5 and further validated by similar position taken by Brown et al.  on vapour compression refrigeration system.
|Food transport by type||Fossil fuel required (miles per gallon)||Fuel required (litres per 100 km)||Estimated distance covered in 2004 (million km)||Total fossil fuel consumed in 2004 (million litres)|
|Rigid over 25t||6.4||44.1||2652||1200|
Several researchers have reported that developed countries currently emit over 15% of greenhouse gases and it is estimated that the emission is likely to increase in view of continuous population explosion. Third world countries are now faced with this same challenge as industries emerge with little or no regard to environmental standards. Of most concern is the emission of carbon dioxide (CO2), sulphur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NO) all resulting from the burning of fossil fuel which is widely reported to be a major contribution to acid rain and air pollution. Preserving food system consumes about 20% world energy and as a result of this action, the earth temperature continues to rise with no end in sight.
Copenhagen conference on climate change has given more impetus to increased global temperature rise which is a pointer to continuous global warming and depletion of ozone layer. World leaders have failed to reach a census agreement on mitigating earth temperature rise at Copenhagen conference in 2009. The accord which gives a clear political road map to constrain carbon emission in short and long term basis failed to provide implementation strategy to effectively monitor member countries. The Copenhagen agreement developed a robust and sustainable approach on which there was for the first time a consensus opinion among several countries. One of the laudable agreement in the conference is to limit the maximum global average temperature rise to no more than two degrees Celsius, subject to further review in 2015. Although, this agreement has been criticized by a lot of researchers, especially in vulnerable countries where the adverse effects of the climate change are more pronounced. Their position was anchored on the premise that 1.5 °C remain the most sustainable earth temperature rise. Also, of critical importance to note in the conference is the unanimous commitment among member countries to reduce overdependence on fossil fuel in energy application. Fossil fuel is believed to be a major contribution to climate change and global warming and the conference agreed to explore renewable energy source as a sustainable alternative.
It has been established in many literatures  and  that emissions such as CO, SO, and NO, from diesel engine driven vapour compression refrigeration system contribute to long-range environmental disaster as evidenced in the depletion of ozone layer and resulting in increased water level rises. Although CO2 and SO2 emissions have been substantially reduced through improved technological innovations in developed countries, Third world countries continue to suffer from effect of emission of CO and CO2. China and United States remain the leading emission of greenhouse gas and these emissions continue to impact developing countries negatively. Table 6 shows some of the greenhouse gas emission from fossil fuel energy in 2005 which ranked United States as the highest CO2 emission followed by the European Union and the China.
|Continent/Country||CO2 emission||GHG emission from Agriculture||GHG emission from fossil fuel||Ratio of energy to Agriculture GHG|
Environmental impact of these greenhouse gases is shown in Table 7. The gaseous pollutants are analysed in terms of its potential to precipitate greenhouse effect, ozone layer depletion, acid rain effect and smog. These data are based on publication from the literature as shown in the references cited.
|Emissions from DEVCRS||GHG effect||Ozone depletion||Acid rain precipitation||Smog|
|NO and N2O||z||x/y||x||x|
Where, x stands for potential contribution and y indicates negligible influence to the effect under study while z indicates ‘may not be a general contributor’. DEVCRS stands for Diesel engine vapour compression refrigeration system.
It is also of interest in many literatures to analyse the role of each of the gaseous emission in terms of their potentials to cause greenhouse effect. Table 8 below presents literature assessment of gaseous emission majorly from diesel engine compression system. CO2 is projected to be the major contribution of greenhouse gas with the growth rate of 0.4% and existing concentration of 345 ppm. This analysis reveals that sustainable measures need to be taken to contain this predicted growth rate.
|Emission||Existing concentration (ppm)||Annual projected growth rate (%)||Contribution to greenhouse effect (%)||Reference|
|CH4||1.64||1.0||8||Xu et al. |
|N2O||0.34||0.2||18||Duan et al. |
Preserving fresh food mainly vegetable under sub-zero weather condition is another medium through which energy is being drained in vapour compression refrigeration system . The heating capacity of the refrigeration system is made to operate in reverse cycle when the ambient temperature is noticed at 30 °C while the effective refrigeration capacity of the unit is set at 0 °C. This process is mandatory to sustain green vegetable for almost a month and process is acknowledged in the literature as energy demanding  and . This energy consumption is phenomenon and it is estimated that this process could account for 2% of world energy demand .
The principle of vapour compression technology has to, to a larger extent, prolong the shelf life of fresh food and it is noteworthy to emphasize that this technology is done at the detriment of the nature. The world is currently under serious threat due to climate change and it is predicted that its adverse effect will be more pronounced in the coming years if alternative methods are not sought to tackle the effect of food chain. van Hauwermeiren et al.  have reported on the need to reduce food preservation time as the only viable way to reduce its impact on the environment. According to Duan et al. , reducing food preservation time could only worsen shelf storage life and farmers are likely to be at the receiving end. They recommended 5% slight reduction in storage with humidity monitoring could reduce refrigeration load by 9.25% which will ultimately reduce total store energy load. Table 9 shows some of the existing alternatives to vapour compression refrigeration system as reported in the literature. Some of these technologies are still at the experimental stage but their potential to compete with vapour compression system is explored and presented as reported in the literatures. All these alternatives seem to be facing development barriers at one stage or the other. In case of eutectic system, it is reported to be suitable for short delivery distance since the tube that contains the eutectic solution (phase change material) still needs to be charged from main power . This is a major drawback to the usage of eutectic system because main power supply may sometimes depend on fossil fuel powered energy system which is a major threat to environmental sustainability. Further analysis of Table 9 shows significant improvement in some of the alternatives presented but a lot still need to be done to raise the theoretical Carnot efficiency of some alternatives to practical performance.
|Method||Predicted efficiency (%)||Developmental state||Coefficient of performance (%)||Limitation barriers||Sustainability and prospect|
|Eutectic||30–40||Commercial||40–50%||Already in use||Average|
|Thermotunnel||50–80||Experimental||No data||Very high||Average|
|Vapour compression system||70–80||Commercial||65%||Already in use|
Another possible way to cut back overdependence on diesel engine driven vapour compression system is to explore environmental friendly energy systems . Dagdougui et al.  also recommended gradual shift from fossil fuel energy to a cleaner and reliable energy. Biofuel energy was considered by Chiellini and Morelli  to be a suitable replacement for fossil fuel. In addition, minimising preservation time could be a more sustainable mean of reducing storage and this could be partly achieved by using railways in transportation of perishable citrus fruits .
There are over four million refrigerated road vehicles worldwide  and the impact of carbon emission from these vehicles accounts for over 40% of world greenhouse gas . Advanced composite materials could be explored by many manufacturers to reduce the impact of insulated panel on refrigerated vehicle engine. Energy consumption in food transport system could be as a result of the weight of insulated panel which is reported to be a payload on food transport in situation where aluminium sheet is used as the internal and external sheet of the reinforcing panel . Insulated bodies of food transport vehicles conveying perishable foodstuffs are measured by the value of overall coefficient of heat transfer (k-value). Thermal conductivity value (k) of aluminium sheet is over 200 W/m K as reported by Dragano et al.  and the influence of ambient temperature is pronounced with higher k value of aluminium sheet . A more sustainable approach is to explore fibre reinforced polymeric composite to replace the internal and external wall sheet of insulated panel. Polymer materials have been reported  to have excellent specific strength properties and high modulus . These peculiar properties could be investigated and processed to develop a comparable panel to replace the aluminium sheets. Significant fossil fuel energy could be saved while exploring this process. In the light of the above, many authors ,  and  have also affirmed that polymer composite hardly dissipates heat and therefore poor conductor of heat. This lower thermal properties of polymer composite could also reduce interference from ambient temperature into the refrigerated chamber thereby reducing thermal load required from the compressor for the cooling system.
In this study, the authors have established the impact of diesel engine driven refrigerated vehicles on the environment and the impact may be critical in the future if sustainable approach is not adopted to minimise energy consumption in food chain. In view of the information and data presented in this research, it appears that world leaders need to be more proactive to avert this imminent catastrophe by developing a road map for energy conservation and mitigation. Fossil fuel energy is not definitely a sustainable energy for the future and its utilization continues to surge despite its damaging effect on the environment. This trend must definitely be checkmated.
The following cogent conclusions are drawn from this study:
This article is part of an extensive research study for PhD work at Tshwane University of Technology, Pretoria, under the supervision of the co-authors and fully supported by the Nigerian Government under the Tertiary Education Trust Fund (TETFUND) to which much appreciation is accorded. The lead author wishes to equally thank the contribution of the co-authors for the time given to check the initial draft of this manuscript and their thorough and constructive criticism of the manuscript which has improved the manuscript in no small measure.